4 Things to Consider When Choosing the Right Fisting Toy for You

fisting toy
Fisting. It’s intense, bold, and not for the easily intimidated. Either you are new to it or a seasoned pro, choosing the right fisting toy is one of the most important decisions you’ll make before diving into the deep end (literally). The wrong sex toy can kill the mood, but the right one? It can deliver mind-shattering sensations that leave you wanting more.
Here’s what you need to know to get the perfect fisting toy that matches your body, your fantasies, and your stamina.
1. Size Is a Statement, But Start Where You’re Comfortable
No one jumps straight into the biggest sex toy on the market (unless you’re looking for a one-way ticket to discomfort). If this is your first time experimenting with fisting, go for a smaller sex toy that lets you ease into the experience. Work your way up to those “holy shit” sizes once you’re comfortable.
If you’ve been exploring for a while, you already know the thrill of chasing that next level. A wider girth, a more complex texture, or something outrageously large might be exactly what you’re ready for. Just make sure your eyes aren’t bigger than… well, you know.
2. Realism or Fantasy? Pick Your Poison
Some fisting toys are hyper-realistic, shaped like an actual hand or fist, complete with veins and curves that mimic the feel of the real thing. These are perfect if you’re into recreating a true-to-life experience. On the flip side, fantasy-shaped sex toys go wild with textures, bulges, and designs meant to push your sensations far beyond anything you’ve felt before.
Ask yourself: are you chasing a lifelike feel, or do you want to be blown away by something straight out of your wildest imagination?
3. Don’t Forget About Those Extra Features
A basic fisting toy is great, but extra features like handles, suction bases, or ridges can take things to a whole new level. Handles give you better control when things get slippery, while suction bases are perfect for hands-free action against a wall, on the floor, or wherever your imagination takes you.
If you’re feeling adventurous, look for sex toys with textures designed to make every inch feel like a new sensation.
4. Your Prep Game Needs to Be Strong
Fisting isn’t a “grab it and go” activity. Prep isn’t just recommended, it’s mandatory. Start with smaller sex toys or fingers to loosen up and get your body ready. Use plenty of lube (seriously, don’t hold back), and take your time warming up. This is your moment, not a race.
Prepping properly sets the tone for a session that feels incredible instead of overwhelming.
The Right Fisting Toy Can Change Everything
A fisting toy is like your partner in creating moments that are intense, rewarding, and memorable. Whether you’re looking for a realistic design, a fantasy-inspired shape, or something massive that makes you feel like a badass, the right sex toy is out there waiting for you.
When you’re ready to explore fisting toys that are as bold and daring as you are, check out Mr. Hankey’s Toys. Known for their expertly crafted designs and high-quality materials, their collection offers something for every level of fisting enthusiast.